I almost wish I had reviewed these two the other way round.

The Brabus came first. Then this one, the standard #1 in sage green, and it took about a day to work out what the Brabus had that this does not. The flair, the punch, the drama. The stuff that made it a beast.

What you get here is simple, safe, well made and cute to look at. Point A to point B, it will be good. It is also the definition of a car, and once you have driven the Brabus it is hard to go back.

Sage green smart #1 Pro+ Core parked under trees in Singapore, front three-quarter view with the full-width light bar lit
Same body as the Brabus, none of the red. Photo: eevee.sg

Cute, and it knows it

In this green it is a pretty thing. Round headlights, a full-width light bar front and back, a floating roof and a cabin that looks a size bigger than the car underneath it. The Brabus wears the same body with a scowl. This one looks like it would apologise if you bumped into it.

The little smart touches are all still here. The oval door handles, the circles and ovals inside, the sunshade switch I liked in the Brabus. The design is nice. The materials are the problem.

The round charge port door on the rear quarter of the sage green smart #1 Pro+ Core
Even the charge port is a circle. Photo: eevee.sg
Rear view of the sage green smart #1 Pro+ Core showing the full-width light bar, the smart lettering and the Core badge
The rear, with the light bar and the lettering across the tailgate. Photo: eevee.sg

The cabin

The smart #1 Pro+ Core cabin from the back seat, showing the floating centre screen, the three round vents and the black man-made leather front seats
Same layout as the Brabus, in black. Photo: eevee.sg

The doors are almost completely hard, scratchy plastic. Not a strip along the bottom. The whole panel. On a car designed by Mercedes-Benz and sold by the Mercedes dealer, you do not expect that.

There is not nearly as much soft-touch material as you would think. The dash top is fine, the armrest is fine, and most of the rest is the plastic you get in cars at half the money. The Brabus had the same problem and made up for it in other ways. This one does not.

The front door panel of the smart #1 Pro+ Core with its oval grab handle and hard grey plastic trim
The door. Nice shape, hard plastic from top to bottom. Photo: eevee.sg

The seats are man-made leather, ventilated, and comfortable. The car is small but a bit tall, so you get a nice driving position. The centre console is the same big, bulky lump as the Brabus, with a covered bin, a couple of trays, and not much else.

The doors are almost completely hard, scratchy plastic. On a car designed by Mercedes-Benz, you do not expect that.

Tech and screens

The smart #1 Pro+ Core dashboard from the driver's seat, with the 12.8-inch floating screen, round vents and the two-spoke steering wheel
The same 12.8-inch screen as the Brabus, and manual vents. Photo: eevee.sg

The good news is the same good news as the Brabus. Same UI, same nice big screen, same clear driver display, same easy-to-use reversing cameras. Wireless CarPlay and Android Auto are in. None of it is complicated and none of it got in my way.

And manual air vents. Always a godsend.

The slim driver display of the smart #1 Pro+ Core behind the steering wheel, showing 325 km of range, with no head-up display on the windscreen above it
The driver display. In the Brabus there was a head-up display above it. Here there is windscreen. Photo: eevee.sg

Now what is missing. No head-up display. No wireless phone charger, which much cheaper cars have built in. No auto parking. And in place of the Brabus's Beats system there are five speakers, and they are passable.

The driver aids are decent. Nothing to write home about. Adaptive cruise, lane keeping, blind spot, cross-traffic alert, and the odd bings and bongs.

The smart #1 Pro+ Core drive settings screen showing regenerative braking set to Low, with Medium and High beside it and an s-Pedal one-pedal mode
Low, Medium, High, or s-Pedal. It will be back on Medium tomorrow. Photo: eevee.sg

The daily annoyance is the regen. Three levels plus a one-pedal mode, and the car goes back to Medium every time you start it. If you like it at Medium, good for you. If not, it is a trip into the menus every morning.

The drive

It is not a slow car. 110 kW is the Cat A cap and the sheet says 9 seconds to 100 km/h, but off the line it feels pretty quick. Forget the Brabus, though, and it is still not as fast as a lot of EVs we have driven.

The rest is easy. The ride is comfortable. The cabin is quiet. It slots into HDB carparks without thinking, auto parking or not. It is an easy car to drive and a pleasant one to commute in.

What it does not have is a personality. The Brabus was not just fast. You felt special in it. Here, you feel like you are in a good EV, and that's it.

Rear three-quarter view of the sage green smart #1 Pro+ Core with its black roof, parked on a tree-lined carpark in Singapore
High tail, black roof, 19-inch wheels. Photo: eevee.sg

The back seat and the boot

The back seat of the smart #1 Pro+ Core in black man-made leather, seen through the open rear door
Two adults, same as the Brabus. Photo: eevee.sg
The boot of the smart #1 Pro+ Core with the tailgate open, 323 litres with the seats up
323 litres. The weekly shop, and not much more. Photo: eevee.sg

Space in the back is not great. Two adults fit, legroom is tight behind a tall driver, and the rear seat slides forward if you need the boot more than the legroom.

The boot is 323 litres with the seats up, which is small even for this size of car. Same as the Brabus: fine for the weekly shop, not a family car.

Living with it in Singapore

Range is decent. smart quotes 420 km on the WLTP cycle. On my loan the screen showed 325 km with the battery at 77 per cent, which points to a little over 420 km on a full charge, so the claim holds up. The car's long-term counter read 19.0 kWh/100 km over about 1,500 km of press-fleet driving at an average of 25 km/h, against an official 17.4.

The smart #1 Pro+ Core trip screen showing 325 km of remaining range and an average consumption of 19.0 kWh/100 km over 1,496 km
325 km showing at 77 per cent, and 19.0 kWh/100 km on the long-term counter. Photo: eevee.sg

On charging, smart quotes 150 kW DC and 10 to 80 per cent in about half an hour. AC is 7.4 kW, which is on the slow side for a carpark charger. Fine overnight.

The Core is a Cat A car, so the COE is the cheaper one and the road tax band is well below the Brabus's S$4,415 a year. That is the practical case for this car over the other one, and it is a real one.

smart is distributed here by Cycle & Carriage, the Mercedes-Benz people, which explains the design and makes the plastics harder to forgive. The brand's story, from a two-seat city car to a Mercedes and Geely joint venture, is in Who is smart.

Buying one

The #1 Pro+ Core is S$207,000 with COE on Cycle & Carriage's November list, and that number includes a S$45,000 trade-in subsidy. No car to trade in, no S$45,000. Get the figure for your situation in writing, because it moves with every COE round.

This is a price game. At S$207,000, with a Cat A COE and Cat A road tax, the Core is the sensible smart. The Brabus is around S$240,000 and a Cat B car, and it is the one you will remember.

The closer fight is with its own cousins. The Zeekr X Urban sits on the same Geely platform, is the same size, is also Cat A, and was S$219,999 with COE on its October list. Its cabin is plusher and its steering wheel is one of the nicest I have held. The Volvo EX30 is the same platform again, Cat A, and S$250,000. Below all of them, the AION UT at S$183,100 does the small, cute, sensible job for a lot less. Line them all up in our compare tool.

The verdict

This is a car you test drive, and maybe not a car you buy.

If there is a good deal on, a promotion, a number that undercuts the rivals, I would buy it, because it ticks the box for what you want from an EV. Decent range, comfortable, quiet, easy to drive, easy to park, nice to look at. At list, I would go and sit in the Zeekr first.

It scores 6.9 because the screen, the ride and the range are good and the plastics and the missing kit are real. It gets a 6 for Soul because it is one of the more forgettable cars I have driven, and the Brabus is in the same showroom.