In our Model 3 review I called it one of my favourite cars, full stop. I still mean it.
The Model Y is that car with a higher driving position and a lot more room behind you. It has been the world's best-selling car for three years running, and after a loan I get it. It is premium. It is comfortable. It drives well, the seats are lovely and the screen is still the best in the business.
But it wears all of that a little more quietly. If the Model 3 is a spaceship, the Model Y is the same ship after someone told it to dress for a meeting. Softer and bigger, more business casual. It commands the road because you sit high and it is simply a large object. It does not fizz the way the 3 does.
Part of that is the body. Part of it is this variant, the Cat A one. More on that below.
Inside
Tesla through and through. Same wheel, same near-empty dash, same one big screen doing every job in the car. Minimalism as a religion.
What surprised me is how plush it feels. Everything you touch is soft, all the way up the doors and across the dash. The build feels heavy and solid, the kind of solid that makes a car feel like it will last. The light bar that curls around the front of the cabin is a small thing that kept pleasing me every time I got in.
The seats are excellent and the ventilation is strong. The aircon is top class, and with Grok you can set the exact temperature you want by talking to it, which sounds trivial until you have done it in traffic. The lack of physical vents is still a gripe. This is a Tesla, and you knew that when you walked in.
The wireless charging pads are quick and simple, and there is a lot of storage everywhere.
The sound system is the one place the Y falls behind the 3. It is a similar setup, and it is not as good here. My read is that it is the same kit trying to fill a much bigger room.
Grok and the screen
Grok remains a masterclass in how an in-car assistant should work. Nothing else on sale here comes close. The nearest I have used is the Google-based system in the Volvo EX30, and Grok is still a step ahead.
It also fixes most of the little Tesla annoyances I have moaned about before. Vents, temperature, the setting buried three taps deep: you just ask. In the Model 3 it taught me the car. In the Model Y it did it again.
The app is the best there is. It is market-leading for a reason.
The Tesla learning curve applies in full, and it is the same curve I climbed in the 3. There is no gear lever; you swipe a strip on the edge of the screen. The side mirrors and the steering column are adjusted through a menu. One-pedal driving is always on and cannot be switched off, so budget a slightly awkward first day. There is no Android Auto and no CarPlay, and after a while I stopped caring.
Tesla, like Apple, does not compromise on any of this. If that is the way you like your tech, nothing else will do.
The drive: this is the Cat A one
Here I have to be honest about the variant. This is the 110 kW car, built to fit under Singapore's Cat A cap, and Tesla quotes 9.6 seconds to 100 km/h. It does not accelerate with the ferocity of the Model 3 I drove. You feel the weight, and you feel the leash.
The ride is comfortable and the cabin is quiet. But it drives like an SUV, because it is one. It is big and boxy, and it wobbles a little through corners where the Model 3 stays flat. That low, sedan-shaped precision is the thing I missed most.
It drives well. But it drives like an SUV: big, boxy, a little wobbly through corners where the Model 3 stays flat.
Which is probably the wrong comparison. The Model Y belongs alongside the BYD Sealion 7 and the XPENG G6, not its own sibling. Against those it is the better car. You just lose something the 3 has.
The Cat B Model Y, with the bigger battery and more power, might scratch that itch. I have not driven it, so that stays on paper.
Driver aids: one hit, one miss
Our car had every software option switched on.
Autosteer and lane keeping are excellent. We do not get Full Self-Driving here, and I am a little envious of the markets that do, but what we get is very good. The XPENG G6 is the only rival I have driven that gets close.
Autopark is the miss. In the Model 3 it was superb. Here I had to take over about half the time: odd angles, hesitation, a bay it should have nailed and did not. I do not know whether the bigger body is the problem. I only know it fell short of what I expected from a Tesla, and behind what XPENG manages.
The family stuff
This is where the Model Y earns its badge. Rear legroom is generous and the rear seats are properly comfortable. The boot is huge, the frunk is genuinely useful, and the rear seats fold at the touch of a button in the boot. For a family, that is a very complete package.
Living with it in Singapore
A loan of Singapore traffic, carparks and heat, and the Model Y never felt like hard work. The aircon copes, the seats keep you cool, and the app means the car is cold before you reach it.
Tesla's configurator sheet quotes 488 km of estimated range. With the battery at 75 per cent the screen showed 327 km, which points to a little over 430 km on a full charge. It is the car's own estimate, so take it as a guide.
Then there is the Supercharger network. You plug in and walk away, and the bill goes to your Tesla account. I did not charge the car on this loan, and I did not need to. The car can also use every public charger everyone else uses.
On looks, I will be honest: they are not for me. It is a little bulbous, a little heavy in the rear. I understand why, because the space and the aerodynamics both come from that shape. I would still pick the 3 on the driveway.
There is no distributor. Tesla sells direct, online, at a fixed price, and services the cars itself at Toa Payoh. How Tesla went from a S$15,000 surcharge on its first car here to the badge on every third carpark is in Who is Tesla? And if you want to see where the software is heading, we sat in the Cybercab when it came through Toa Payoh.
Buying one
On Tesla's Singapore configurator sheet dated 8 October 2026, the Model Y Premium Rear-Wheel Drive 110 was S$216,999, including an estimated COE bid of S$111,480. The Model 3 Premium Long Range, the Cat B car I reviewed, was the same S$216,999 on the same sheet. The Cat B Model Y, the Premium Long Range Rear-Wheel Drive with 691 km and 5.8 seconds claimed, was S$236,999.
So the choice between the Y and the 3 is not about money. It is about whether you want the seat height and the space, or the speed and the sharper drive. I would take the 3. Most families will take the Y, and they will not be wrong.
Against the rest of the market, the XPENG G6 Air is the direct rival: another Cat A SUV with the same 110 kW, listed at S$224,999 with COE on XPENG's October list, with a bigger boot and the full driver-assist suite in the box. The BYD Sealion 7 Premium RWD was S$218,888 on BYD's 8 October list, and it is a Cat B car. I have not driven it, so that stays on paper. Line them up in our compare tool.
The verdict
The Model Y is a market-leading electric SUV, and it shows why Tesla is still ahead on the things people live with every day: the screen, the assistant, the app, the ease of it all.
Personally, I would have the Model 3. It is sharper and quicker, and it looks better to my eye. But if you need the space and the seat height, the Model Y gives up almost nothing of what makes the 3 great.
It is not cheap, and unlike the 3, it has real competition. That is what keeps it out of the nines.